Easter Treats and more!


2026 Easter Order Form

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

  • Easter is around the corner and we have delicious pot pies, quiche, savory entrees and sides and of course your favorite PIE!

    When you invite First Slice to your table you not only take the burden off yourself but you also help fill a plate of someone in need. Our sweet treats are even sweeter when you know that you are helping others. As a staple of our community, First Slice continues to work towards our mission of providing for those who need it most. So sit back with a slice of pie knowing that someone else is enjoying one too.

    Pickups are Saturday April 5th and Sunday April 5th. Manor and Montrose stores will be open from 10AM to 4PM Saturday and Sunday. The Andersonville location will be open on Saturday from 10AM to 8PM and on Sunday from 10AM to 6PM.

    If your favorite First Slice treat is not included on this order form, please call one of the cafes directly to see if we can take that special order!

  • Pies


    (small serves 3-5; large serves 10-12)
  • Price: $26.00
  • Price: $32.00
  • Price: $28.00
  • Price: $36.00
  • Price: $26.00
  • Price: $32.00
  • Price: $28.00
  • Price: $36.00
  • Price: $27.00
  • Price: $34.00
  • Price: $26.00
  • Price: $32.00
  • Price: $32.00
  • Price: $32.00
  • Price: $32.00
  • Price: $39.00
  • Price: $32.00
  • Price: $32.00
  • Price: $32.00
  • Price: $32.00
  • Price: $34.00
  • Price: $33.00
  • Price: $18.00
  • Price: $18.00
    Vegan Carrot Cake with Easter Carrot Topping
  • Price: $30.00
    Vegan Carrot Cake with Easter Carrot Topping

  • Quiche for breakfast, brunch, or lunch!

  • Price: $34.00
    (serves 6-9)
  • Price: $38.00
    (serves 6-9)
  • Price: $34.00
    (serves 6-9)
  • Price: $38.00
    (serves 6-9)
  • Price: $36.00
    (spinach, mushrooms, sun-dried tomatoes, and goat cheese – serves 6-9)
  • Price: $40.00
    (spinach, mushrooms, sun-dried tomatoes, and goat cheese – serves 6-9)
  • Price: $38.00
    (serves 6-9)
  • Price: $42.00
    (serves 6-9)
  • Price: $38.00
    (Spanish Chorizo, Manchego Cheese, onions – serves 6-9)
  • Price: $42.00
    (Spanish Chorizo, Manchego Cheese, onions) – serves 6-9)

  • Savory Pot Pies

  • Price: $25.00
    (small serves 3-5)
  • Price: $38.00
    (large serves 6-9)
  • Price: $28.00
    (small serves 3-5)
  • Price: $40.00
    (large serves 6-9)
  • Price: $22.00
    (small serves 3-5)
  • Price: $32.00
    (large serves 6-9)

  • Sides and Entrees

  • Price: $36.00
    3 pieces
  • Price: $120.00
    10 pieces
  • Price: $27.00
    Picadillo
  • Price: $27.00
    Curry Chicken
  • Price: $25.00
    Feta Cheese and Spinach
  • Price: $20.00
    (small serves 3-5)
  • Price: $50.00
    (large serves 10-12)
  • Price: $25.00
    (small serves 3-5)
  • Price: $60.00
    (large serves 10-12)
  • Price: $20.00
    (small serves 3-5)
  • Price: $38.00
    (large serves 10-12)
  • Price: $30.00
    (serves 10-12)
  • Price: $18.00
    (small serves 3-5)
  • Price: $35.00
    (large serves 10-12)
  • Price: $18.00
    (small serves 3-5)
  • Price: $40.00
    (large serves 10-12)
  • Price: $35.00
    (small serves 3-5)
  • Price: $65.00
    (large serves 10-12)
  • Price: $65.00
    (small serves 3-5)
  • Price: $165.00
    (large serves 10-12)
  • Price: $27.00
    (small serves 3-5)
  • Price: $55.00
    (large serves 10-12)
  • Price: $22.00
    (small serves 3-5)
  • Price: $50.00
    (large serves 10-12)
  • $0.00

  • Orders guaranteed if received by Thursday, April 17th at 11:59PM .

    Pickups are April 19th & 20th.







    Please note, you will be able to pick up your order AFTER your designated time, but NOT BEFORE your designated time!

  • Please review your order! If you need to make changes from subsequent screens, you will need to re-enter all of your choices. (Sorry!)

    PLEASE NOTE: These prices do not include taxes. Taxes will be charged on the Paypal website.