Andersonville Location:

5357 N Ashland Ave
Chicago, IL 60640
Phone: (773) 275-4297

Public: Damen Bus #50 – Balmoral Stop


Monday-Thursday 10am–9pm
Friday 10am-10pm
Saturday 9am-10pm
Sunday  10am-8pm

Here’s What Our Customers Say:

“I came to First Slice on the recommendation of Nadene, the owner Of Green Sky (Real cool stuff by the way) and next door neighbor of 1st Slice. The place has a fresh friendly neighborhood feel.  I got a few healthy looking vegetarian salad type items to go, and the black bean soup (trying to follow Dr.’s orders on not eating too much meat.

“They were all really good especially the soup. I have to fess up that you can’t go to a pie cafe and NOT get pie. . . right?”

“First off, the staff here is crazy friendly.  The decor has a very bright, cheerful vibe to it.  On top of that, the selection of food, coffee drinks and pie (mmm) can’t be beat.”

“We’ve driven by this place so many times but regret not stopping sooner. This place in incredibly charming and the food was wonderful. The prices are very low considering the  quality and size of the portions!”

Just came across this gem of a review for our newest cafe location when we first debuted in Andersonville! Click HERE to check it out! Thank you Chicagoist!


Special Events: Coming soon

Join us on February 8 and 9 for our Pre-Valentine’s Day Specials.

Click here to learn more!